I own an MTD-designed 3205 and an IH 1250.
I think what it boils down to for me is that the vintage equipment is built primarily with reliability and functionality in mind. The MTD design is built with more of an eye towards user friendliness, ergonomics, and is designed around a price point to more of an extent than the IH models.
The end result is that the IH unit wins out in the ruggedness in some areas while the MTD unit is a tractor that is easier to spend continuous hours of use on.
I have beat my 3205 up and it keeps on going. Aside from cosmetics and steering, the new XT3 units still share a lot in common with the 2000/3000 Series Cubs.
At the end of the day, I pick the 1250 if I want to take my time and enjoy the work being done. If I want it done quick and easily, I go for the 3205. I keep it around for the wife as well, since she is comfortable operating it - which is something to say considering she has zero experience with outdoor power equipment.
I have no doubt that a well maintained XT3 would last 20+ years.
|